Quote:
Mike T.- I'm not trying to start an argument with you, but I do find your dismissal of this figure as "just a custom" a bit off putting. As a very long time member of the GI Joe community, I'd be surprised if you didn't acknowledge how integrated customizing is in the Joe community at large all the way back to the beginning. I'd even go so far as to say that it's almost fundamental and certainly more pervasive in this hobby than just about any other.
I don't disagree. To me, customizing is an essential part of the Joe experience, regardless of skill or talent level. However, in this case, even you would have to agree that a percentage of the price (and, likely, a good percentage of the price) is based on the perception that this is a "Con" release. If Kevin made this figure and sold it on Ebay, it would never fetch this price. But, the NJCC tag adds a substantial amount to the perceived value.
Now, I have no issue with people spending huge quanities of money on whatever they want. But, it's not like this a Chocolate Chip Outback where there are only 6-8 of them in existence and the only way to replicate would be to find 15 year old plastic and paint recipes and hope for the best. This item can be replicated much more easily.
Take items like the DeSimone Jinx. He was still making those for collectors into the 2000's. So, that figure you pay for on Ebay thinking it was sold at the 1993 Joe convention could just as easily be an indistinguisable copy that DeSimone made in his garage a full decade later. In the end, what are you paying for? A piece of Joe history? A copy of a piece of Joe history that wasn't actually part of that history? Or a piece that is aesthically pleasing and enjoyable to you at the price you paid?
Quote:
Also, Mike, I appreciate your pragmatic stance, I always have, but I think "indiscernible" might be a little far. Certainly, any customizer could replicate the figure, just like any other fan made custom show giveaways, but with some of the work and techniques we put to use this time around, a 100% match would unlikely. If for no other reason than the decals aren't available to anyone else, before we get into what Spoon and I went through sculpting/bashing/molding/casting that vest.
I'm not saying that the work isn't top notch. The price bears that out. But, you have to admit that it's much more likely to match this figure than anything that's production quality.
My main point is that if you want a custom, pay what you feel is fair. But, thinking that a custom is part of the Joe line or attached to it in any way is a stretch. If I create a figure in my garage tomorrow and sell it, that's one thing. But, if I take the same figure, invite a friend over, call it the "North Scottsdale G.I. Joe Convention" and get it front paged at Hisstank, it's pretty likely that the figure would sell for substantially more. I'm not sure that's a good thing.