parrish333 wrote:
ogre_h wrote:
parrish333 wrote:
In fact, MJ seems to have gone with the compact versions of the G36, Ak74, ACR, Galil, and HK416. Maybe it saves on plastic cost? It'd be nice to have the standard version of the latter three (as he did with the first two).
.
I'd like standard sizes too. I think he went compact because they look a little cooler. The Galil is the SAR version, which is the mid-size between the full sized ARM which the original Crankcase came with, and the MAR which the new Law came with. The FOS6 isn't in the right scale. Its mag is like a 9mm mag, it reminded me of the Colt SMG 635 series instead of an AR type mag. If it was in scale, the ACR's mag should fit it as they're supposed to fire the same round.
Exactly! I think on some of wave 7, in an effort to make the mag removable, it makes the mags a bit small (FOS6, MP5, Skorpion, Tec9). Def. looks like a 9mm mag for the FOS6. I think I'll make it the Colt SMG equivalent - I'll use it as a fictional 9mm variant of the HK416, more in the SMG/PDW category.
But the G36C and AK74U look pretty dead-on for scale; prob. the Galil too, since as you reminded me, it's the SAR version. Really love those three! The Halo and Aliens rifles are beautiful as well.
ogre_h wrote:
The bbi M4/M203 is still my standard for ARs for Joes.
Just curious - is that the M4 you think is most in scale? It's kind of fun/scary to line up all the M4s I have from various lines and see the wild differences in what should be the same scale. I've lost all bearing on what is even close anymore
I think they probably range from 1:24 to 1:15.
I don't know if they're the most in scale, but bbi's were the most consistent across their various weapons. Their G36, XM8 series (which is compatible with MJ's suppressors by the by) and Ruger Mini 14 were all in scale with each other. MJ's M16A2 is big compared to bbi, but its in scale with his M16/M203 combo and early AKs. So if that's all you use, they'll look right. But if you throw in the series 6 FOS or AKM you'll notice differences. If you look at this image
you can get an idea of some of the submachine guns relative sizes. MJ's TMP and MP7 are close to this picture in relative sizes.
The various XM8s
To me scale is what "looks right". I'm not a scale purist. We've all seen pictures of soldiers with weapons, and we get an idea how they should look with our joes. bbi's weapons look right to me, and since they're in scale with each other, they reinforce the impression of accuracy. For the most part, MJ's series 7 looks right, the FOS6, MP5 and FN FAL seem to be undersized, where most of series 6 was oversized. What helped series 7 for me is that the weapons like the ACR, TMP and Galil looked to be close in scale with both bbi and joe weapons of similar type/scale.
It looks like Series 7's accessories will be more in scale with bbi type weapons. I haven't had a chance to check, but if they look good, I'll break out the pin vice and start making ports.