This isn't for a critique, but just to show that while they may be fugly out of the pack, a little paint can salvage some of the mistakes. I've only touched-up Baroness and Scarlett, as they're the only ones I really had an issue with. They're butt ugly right out the pack like I said, but with a little paint here and there, the actress' likenesses start to come out a little more, although still not perfect:
Baroness:
I went over her whole face with a half/half mixture of Elf Flesh and Dwarf Flesh, slimming and shortening her eyebrows down. Then I put more "lipstick" on her to make her lips fuller.
Scarlett:
I mixed up some paint for her hair and filled in where they missed, so she doesn't have the Faith No More haircut. I purposefully went over the hair line with some brush strokes to make it look more natural. Next, I mixed up some pink and painted her lips. Scarlett also got the 25th comic pack crossbow to replace that pick axe looking thing she had.