Hasbro giveth, and Hasbrow taketh away...
My initial thought - OMG they fixed the hips!!!! And they did, truly. gijoey posted earlier that he though the hips were better now, and in hand, I can agree. I dig them. The difference? something we've been saying for a long time now - the angle at which the ball joint is inserted into the waist. The same component parts are there as for other movie figures. But instead of them being inserted upwards, they are inserted straight into the crotch sideways. The result is that you don't have to swivel the first joint at all. The hinge works for lateral movement, and the swivel from the new insertion point allows for forward and backward movement, all without having to monkey.
It's not a Joe hip, which I
think I still prefer. But for the first time ever I can foresee hip articulation better than Joe. It has full range of motion, and now makes the thigh swivel relevant for the first time. You can easily put this hip into a sitting down legs crossed postion.
I am impressed.
Now the taketh away part.
No wrist articulation
No ankle articulation
No mid torso OR waist articulation.
I can almost live with the wrists and ankles. The rest of the arms and legs have Joe styled articulation, double knees, swivel elbows, etc... But the lack of any type of torso movement is a big hurdle here.
Cap and comic Thor have identical articulation, as described above. Hulk is different only in that his hip is inserted upwards - but without a thigh swivel, which is a small improvement over the old style, and he has an action feature that resembles mid torso articulation. I guess it actually is articulated back and forward. But nothing side to side.
As far as action features go, it's actually not bad. It's not intrusive on normal play. Though they click, the arms can still rotate at the shoulder independent of each other. If you want the Hulk smash, you line them up, pull them back past the head and let go, and it simply springs the arms and the upper torso forward. It's almost kind of cool.
Last observation is that Cap is small. His other movie figs were smallish too, so that's not a huge surprise, but it looks (without actually measuring) that he's a nub shorter than the Cap Movie figs even.
I strangely like these, even with the limitations, and I think it's more about how awesome they might have been. The hip upgrade is a HUGE deal - can't say it enough. And they feel like nice solid figures. The sculpts are well done, and they had the potential to be 3 of the finest 1:18 figures I've laid my hands on. With the articulation corner cutting, however, they are simply nice looking things that I'm not sure how much I should bother working on.
_________________
Kwinn_Lives wrote:
you have now won more JCAs than anyone in the history of the award.
Mysterious Stranger wrote:
You sir are the definition of a Renaissance Nerd... you do it all so damn well.